Tartane Leadership Guides

New Manager Guide - The Essential Leadership Skills You Need to Master

by Stephen Caruana|15th July 2025
The transition to management brings a fundamental shift to your job that catches most people off guard. Your value is no longer measured by how well you execute work tasks, but rather by the results your people achieve.

Everything you do ripples through your team. Not just your deliberate actions, but also the way you communicate, how you make decisions, how you show up each day. All of it.

And if no one ever sat you down to teach you how all of this works, you're not alone.

Most leaders aren't given formal guidance. They find themselves in leadership positions because they performed well as individual contributors, or because there was an organisational need as the business grew around them.

Then, seemingly overnight, they're expected to lead with confidence, clarity and strategic foresight, often without any structured support.

It's a significant transition. And the reason it's challenging is because leadership isn't a singular skill, but a collection of them, spanning across domains that aren't always obvious when you start.

The good news is that you don't need to master everything overnight, but you do need to have a clear view of the broader picture.

The Leadership Skills You Need

To be effective in a leadership role, especially as your scope widens, you need to develop your abilities in multiple interconnected areas.

Here's just a few:
  • Relationship Management: leading your team, supporting peers, handling conflict, building trust and influence across all levels
  • Team Development: Feedback, coaching, delegation, hiring well, retaining talent
  • Communication: meetings, written communication, presenting, persuasion, clarity
  • Strategic thinking: making decisions, setting & prioritising goals, handling complexity, financial and organisational awareness
  • Productivity: time management, email, admin, staying focused
  • Self-development: professional network, continuous learning, professional skills
...and more.

At first, you're not going to be good at most of these. But being aware of them, and working steadily to build competence across them, is the start of your transition from accidental manager to an intentional leader.

What's most often missed is how these areas reinforce each other. Good relationships make hard conversations easier, which in turn improves team performance. This allows you to push more work down, knowing it will be done well, and creates more space for strategic thinking. And so on. Everything feeds into everything else.

Every skill you build strengthens your ability to lead well. The sooner you start, the sooner those pieces start coming together.

So let's look at each of these areas more closely to understand what they demand of you and how they show up in day-to-day management.

If you're figuring this out as you go and feel overwhelmed, you don't have to do it alone.

I work with managers and directors who've been promoted into leadership roles but never received formal training. Through personalised mentorship, I provide structured, personalised support tailored to your specific situation and challenges.

You'll develop these interconnected skills systematically with practical, actionable guidance you can apply immediately.

Reach out, and we'll discuss how to get you the support you need to start seeing immediate results!

Stephen
Principal Consultant and Founder
Tartane Leadership

Tell me where I can contact you

    Trust and Relationships

    At the centre of all effective leadership is trust. This becomes clear very quickly once you're responsible for others' work and outcomes.

    Trust is the foundation for honest dialogue, accountability, and performance. It's what allows people to speak up, take ownership, and be honest when something's wrong.

    Don't confuse this with being liked, or being friends with your team. Although you should certainly behave in a friendly, likeable manner. Trust is different, and is It's all about consistent and reliable behaviour.

    A big part of that is doing what you said you will, whether that's an explicit promise or even an implied one such as deadline commitments and meeting agendas. And if you can't deliver on something, say so early. Giving advance warning shows respect.

    This also relates to communicating regularly and clearly. Also, don't use one-on-one meetings just to check on work, but to understand concerns, priorities, and how people are doing.

    Competence matters too. Show up prepared, stay on top of your responsibilities, and demonstrate that you know your stuff. People trust leaders who are capable, not just well-meaning. And when you get something wrong, own it. Accountability is what builds trust, not defensiveness.

    Finally, don't overlook professional conduct and always be respectful. This signals to your team that you take your role, and them, seriously.

    You can't manufacture trust through techniques or frameworks alone. It's built (and very easily eroded) in the small, everyday moments. Your reliability in the small things determines your credibility in the big ones. When your team believes you have their back when things go wrong, and that they'll get the recognition when things go right, they'll give you more in return.

    Without trust, everything else becomes harder. Feedback is met with defensiveness; delegation slides into micromanagement; conflict gets buried instead of resolved.

    Trust is the sine qua non of effective leadership. Without it, nothing else holds.

    Delegation and Ownership

    The shift in focus from executing tasks to managing and leading others to achieve organisational goals is one of the most fundamental changes that comes with leadership.

    You're no longer measured by what you personally accomplish, but by what gets done through your team. This realisation often comes as a surprise to new leaders who built their reputation on delivering results based on their own skills and expertise.

    That means you now need to focus on how to arrange the workforce and workload to achieve the desired outcomes. You must learn to understand what needs to be done, rather than just how to do it. Let your directs handle the "how".

    And the way to do that is by assigning a task as well as the responsibility for achieving the intended outcome of that task.

    Because delegation isn't meant to just hand-off activities. Your direct has to take ownership of the task, while your obligation is to support and coach them as needed.

    This gives them the space to figure things out and grow. It means resisting the urge to jump in every time they do it differently than you would. It means supporting them, not babysitting them.

    Which will feel uncomfortable at first. Letting go is hard, especially when you know you could do it faster or differently. But watching someone struggle, or succeed in their own way, is part of the process. If you don't delegate well, you'll burn out. Worse, your team won't grow. They'll wait to be told, rather than take initiative.

    Then, when that delegated work succeeds, make sure to give them all the credit. A good way to think about it is that success should be delegated too. However, if things go wrong, that's still yours to own. As the delegator, you still retain ultimate accountability.

    Feedback and Development

    Great leadership creates the conditions for people to succeed, and that includes helping them grow. Feedback is your primary tool for that.

    Feedback isn't a one-off event. It's a regular, undramatic rhythm. Like steering a car, it's about small, frequent adjustments that keep things on course. Waiting for annual reviews or formal check-ins is too late. By then, small wins would have faded from view and small problems would have grown. Regular feedback keeps people aligned, motivated, and clear on what good performance looks like.

    Very often, when people think of feedback, they generally think of negative, or corrective feedback. That is indeed part of it, but more importantly, there's positive feedback. Not praise, like "Great job!" which is also necessary, but different. Rather, it's points out specific behaviour to reinforce it and encourage more of it in future. "The way you handled that client issue prevented escalation. That showed good judgement." This makes it easy for your directs to understand exactly what they're doing well, why it's good, and lets them know that they should do more of it.

    Corrective feedback matters just as much, but it only lands well when the environment is right. If your team trusts you and if positive feedback is already a regular habit, not something that only happens when things go wrong, your directs are more likely to receive it without defensiveness or resentment, and act on it.

    Beyond that, you should be thinking about the long-term development of each team member, which goes further than feedback alone. If trust and communication are in place, you'll have a clear understanding of each individual's skills and ambitions. Great managers create deliberate opportunities that stretch people in the right ways and help them move towards their goals.

    Your team's growth is an asset. As they develop, your organisation grows stronger, making you a more effective manager.

    Clarity and Communication

    A lot of leadership issues boil down to the team not being clear on what matters to you, as their manager. This becomes more critical as you move into more senior roles, where your clarity affects even more people and decisions.

    People aren't mind readers. What may seem obvious to you, as a leader, may not be clear to others.

    As the leader, it's your job to make things clear and explicit, not assumed. Which means stating things plainly, and probably repeating yourself more than feels comfortable. Repetition isn't patronising when done well. It's how you build alignment. Especially when things are busy or stressful.

    Saying something once, even clearly, doesn't guarantee it landed. Maybe someone was distracted. Maybe they misunderstood. Either way, it's on you to close that gap.

    Communication is complex, nuanced and one of the more challenging skills to develop. Yet, mastering it delivers some of the greatest returns in leadership effectiveness. Here I'm only touching on its core relevance to leadership and management. There's much more to explore about how to communicate effectively.

    What matters most in this context is to communicate often and clearly, and that this is an ongoing responsibility of your role.

    Decision-Making

    Indecision breaks your team's momentum. Every time your team has to wait for a decision, work stalls. And often, they're waiting not because the issue is complex, but because they're unclear on who owns the decision, or whether they're allowed to act. Which feeds back to the points I made when talking about the importance of trust and delegation.

    As a manager, one of your core responsibilities is to make decisions. Some are big, strategic ones, but many involve the everyday calls that keep work moving. This doesn't mean you have to rush every choice you make, but you need to recognise when you have enough information to move forward. Every delay carries an opportunity cost.

    But it's not enough to be decisive yourself. You also need to create a culture where your team makes decisions promptly, even if they're not perfect. Emphasise that It's better to act, learn, and adjust as needed than to wait indefinitely.

    More information doesn't automatically mean better decisions. The value of acting early, even imperfectly, outweighs the gains of waiting almost every time.

    When you spend too much time gathering information or perfecting a plan, momentum dies and progress slows. In environments with high operational tempo, this can result in missed deadlines and opportunities. Decisions made later can lose their importance, and the cost of delay can outweigh the benefits of having more data.

    Progress comes from momentum, not perfection.

    Ready to stop learning through trial and error?

    Our mentorship programme gives you practical, actionable guidance tailored to your specific challenges. We can go wide across all leadership areas or dive deep into what you need most right now. No courses, no theory. Just personalised support to help you get results.

    Tartane Leadership helps managers become more effective. We focus on the behaviours that help you and your team perform at the highest level and deliver stronger results.

    Talk to us to learn more about how we can help you jumpstart your progress!

    Tell us where to contact you

      Team Dynamics and Cohesion

      It's not enough to focus on individual performance. Your effectiveness as a manager comes from how well your team operates as a whole. You can hire the best people in the world, but if they don't communicate, support each other, or share common norms, they'll underperform.

      The word "culture" is often used within this context, but many treat it as a set of values found on a website or mission statement that we then print out and pin to a wall. Rather, an organisation's culture is the sum total of all the actual behaviours observed and practised day-to-day by everyone within it. For instance, if collaboration is touted as a core value but team members consistently work in silos and hoard information, the actual culture is one of competition and secrecy, regardless of what's written on the wall.

      This holds true whether the organisation in question is the entire company, one of its divisions, or your team including all levels of the hierarchy below you.

      And in your team, it all starts with you. The people who answer to you will take their cues from how you run meetings, how you handle conflict, how you talk about others when they're not present, how you respond to mistakes, and how you balance work demands with personal boundaries. You're constantly modelling what's acceptable and what isn't, often without even realising it.

      An organisation's culture isn't moulded overnight, but it will form regardless. The question is whether you're shaping it, or letting it take shape on its own. Left unguided, culture often defaults to the loudest voices or the most entrenched habits, which may not serve your team's performance or wellbeing.

      So you need to be intentional about it. And the way to be intentional is to develop your abilities across those interconnected areas of leadership we talked about at the very beginning. When you're competent in these broader leadership skills, you're better equipped to shape the behaviours and interactions that define your team's culture.

      Final Thoughts

      Leadership isn't an innate gift. It's a set of interconnected, learnable skills. And no one teaches them to you all at once, if at all. In fact, most people figure them out mid-flight, adjusting as they go.

      The good news is that the work pays off. The better you get at this, the easier it feels. Not because the problems disappear, but because you're better equipped to handle them. You'll get more done through others, retain great people, reduce stress, and build a team that performs even when you're not in the room.

      The skills you develop as a leader will serve you throughout your career, and the people you develop will carry those lessons forward, multiplying your impact beyond your own efforts.

      Management is challenging work, but it's also some of the most rewarding work you'll ever do.

      Stephen



      You've read the what and the why. If you want help with the how, tailored to your situation and your team, I can help. We'll work together to sharpen your leadership, strengthen your team, and drive results that move your career and organisation forward.
      Ready to make that happen? Let's talk. Contact me here, and I'll personally get back to you ASAP. Looking forward to our conversation!